James (Schaffrillas)’s review published on Letterboxd:
A fascinating rewatch in a post Hundreds of Beavers world. Compared to that movie's universally appealing sense of humor, this one is so ultra specific and so niche that I can see why it only majorly took off among my circle of friends. A couple stretches are a bit dryer than I (looking at you, cruise ship bit) and while there are so many comedic swings that still hit home runs for me, there are a surprising number of ones that fall a bit short. I was always enamored with the low-budget wit and ingenuity of this one, but now that I've seen those same elements on a much grander scale from the same team, it's hard to justify keeping this one at the same score. But it's still great! Captain Seafield still remains one of the funniest cinematic protagonists I've ever seen, this movie inarguably has the better song compared to its successor, and don't even get me started on the damn ghost army